I think it’s high time I start actually getting around to reviewing things since I have no life right now haha. I’ve had a lot of things for a good long while now, so I should start getting them out. One of those things are the Composite Reflex Wide-Track Stirrups. I’ve had them since June 2017, so it’s been nearly 2 years that they’ve been in my possession. I’ve had the regular, Composite Lightweight Stirrups for a much shorter amount of time, but this will be a bit of a compare and contrast for the two stirrup types.
First I’ll go over the composite lightweight stirrups. I believe I bought these probably when I got my saddle – April of 2017 (sorry guys my memory doesn’t go back that far and I’m too lazy to really go back through my pictures lol. Because it could’ve also been like Jan or Feb 2017…. lol). After watching eventing in 2016, and beginning to follow some bloggers’ adventures, the ERM series, and anything else eventing that I could latch on to, I was very intrigued by the black stirrup look. I grew up riding in the hunter ring, so it was navy coat, tan breeches, black boots, oakbark tack and Fillis irons. I had also been out of the English world for 13 years, and eventing was so very different from the other English disciplines as well. It was bright, it was fun, there was color, and after riding Western with all that bling I was really loving all the xc possibilities.
After trying out my mom’s regular Fillis irons, they were heavy and the balls of my feet would hurt like crazy with those – so much so it’d make my toes numb. So I searched around for a stirrup with more padding, and that’s when I found the composite stirrups. I was immediately interested in those – perhaps they wouldn’t be as hard as metal, and they’d be lighter as well as having a nice, thick pad. So, I grabbed the composite lightweight stirrups – in royal of course because 1) color and 2) it matched all of Amber’s royal accessories and 3) because why not? I really liked them when they first came; they were just as light as advertised, and I loved how the royal looked so fun with Amber’s stuff. They were nicely padded, and I could tell that my feet felt a lot better in these.
But, after only 3 or so rides, the balls of my feet started hurting again. And I was really disappointed. I really liked these, but numb feet are no joke and quite painful. Since there were good things with these stirrups, I decided to stick with the composite but search for other options. At that time, a few bloggers were discussing how their feet felt better in a wide stirrup bed – distribution of pressure and all that. I hadn’t ever really thought of that, especially after being away from English for a while, but once I read that it made so much sense – my feet never hurt like that in Western stirrups, even when the length was short. Of course – wider foot bed. So with that light bulb in mind I went back to RW, found the composite wide tread stirrups, and snapped them up.
I was quite hesitant with these at first. There was no padding – only a lot of grip that I was afraid would still hurt quite a bit when I used them. I nearly got the black with the blue again, but I thought the all-black would be a good compare/contrast for me. And it turned out that I just really love the all-black look with my saddle. Can’t quite tell you why, but I do lol. But, since I’ve been using them for about the past two years, I’ve never looked back.
At first, my feet hurt a little bit. I wasn’t used to the grate on stirrups, so I’d take my feet out, roll my toes and check to see if my toes were numb. While the pressure was different, I didn’t have any numb toes. And then, after about 3 rides, my feet stopped hurting. And they haven’t hurt since. The only time my feet did hurt was when it was cold, I was wearing the wrong socks with my non-winter tall boots, and my entire foot was numb haha. But that wasn’t the stirrups’ fault haha. Once my foot got used to the newer stirrups, my feet have been great. My arches have hurt less, and these definitely distribute the pressure a lot more evenly than a narrower foot bed. Personally, I think these have helped my knees a little as well, but to be really honest I can’t completely tell. I still get a few pangs, but they’re few and far between than the once a week when I rode in the Fillis irons and the narrow composite ones.
The grate on these stirrups is super grippy. I think my feet have come out of these stirrups exactly twice – once in my lesson with Lit when he spooked at the canter and I nearly fell off the side (and once I jammed my foot back in the stirrup I had to actually lift my leg up to reposition my foot), and the second time when Soxie got too close to the rail and knocked my foot out of it lol. So these have a lot of really good grip to them. I’ve even used them with my dressage saddle, and I really like that even with a draped leg, my feet stay in the stirrup right where I place them – no slipping and sliding. Plus, because they’re composite, they’re very light, which is a wonderful change to very heavy western saddles. Granted, English saddles are generally much lighter, but I liked that these added very little weight.
This isn’t to say that the lightweight composite stirrups aren’t good. Not at all – I really liked them when I used them, especially with their fun, colorful options, and they’re a great stirrup for a lot of people. And at a little over $30, you really can’t beat that. For me, though, I needed something with a wider tread that distributed pressure, and those are a better fit for me than the regular ones. The wide tread comes in at a little over $40, so these absolutely don’t break the bank, either. Also, the regular composite stirrups don’t have the grip like the wide tread does, so I could see my feet coming out of those easier than the wide tread. The padding is a pretty good grip – it’ll stick to the bottom of your boots, but if you’re jumping or running xc where it’s a lot easier for your feet to slip around, I would suggest going for the wide tread versus the regular.
For that, I give the Wide Tread stirrups a 5/5, and the Lightweight stirrups a 4/5.
For anyone eyeing these stirrups, I hoped my review helped!
I’ve been recently looking at the reflex wide treads as well, so thank you for the review. The light weight scares me off a little. I like a bit of weight so the iron stays under me in case I do lose it but I cant necessarily afford the ones that I like so….I may snag a pair of these and see how they feel
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m glad my review helped! So far I haven’t noticed that these flop around a lot if my foot isn’t in the stirrup. Yeah it’s definitely hard to decide what to get when there are so many options!
fwiw Sara i lost my stirrups *way* less after switching to lightweight composites. they don’t swing off the foot as easily when they’re less heavy. obvi it can still happen, but i noticed an overall reduction in lost stirrups (esp at canter) when i first switched to these stirrups in 2014.
LikeLiked by 1 person
These are intriguing and I like the price… Thanks for the review!
LikeLiked by 1 person
That was the main reason I tried them – the price is so affordable!
I have some of these and they are super comfortable, but I stopped jumping in them after having a few scares. I think I might try adding them to my trail saddle at some point.
Oh no! I’m sorry that happened! In that case, they’d probably be great for the trail saddle!
i’ve been pretty happy with these stirrups over the years. they’re simple and a good value for the price. the thing that surprised me the most with them was how much lighter my whole saddle was — i had never really realized just how heavy the old fillis irons were. but when we were hauling out for every ride one winter, slogging the saddles back and forth to the trailer, it made a HUGE difference!
i have some fancy stubben maxi grips on my jump saddle now (with treads that have a serious bite haha) so the compositis live happily on my dressage saddle
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh I’m glad to know they’ve worked really well for you! And omg how light they are makes such a difference lol. I’ve been looking into other jump stirrups too – not because the composites are failing, but I’m thinking a turned stirrup will help my knees even more lol. I’d love to read a review on the Stubben maxi grips!
The price can’t be beat! I know lots of companies now make composite stirrups, but I do like the idea of the wider footbed. Thanks for the review!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh I hadn’t seen that other companies have some! I’ll have to look into those.
Thanks for the review as I was looking at them. .First time on your page and I was disappointed to see you impose a tail bag on your horse. How would you like someone to put you in a room with buzzing flies, then give you a ” mini” fly swatter ( narrow and thin) so you can only kill some of the biting flies at a time. A horse needs their entire tail to fan out to get more of the flies. Then try hitting yourself hard with a long braided fake horse tail. Does that feel good to you? Imagine having to wack yourself with a heavy hard braid constantly over and over day and night. And because the braid and bag is so thin you don’t always get the fly you just get bit by the fly. I don’t how this trend for tail bags became so popular, but as horse owners we can help our horses by putting our self in in their place before we try something.